Old Timer ... name this ML pitcher

[doc mercer]

I had over 200 career wins

I had over 2000 career strikeouts

3 times I played in the All Star Game

2 times I won a Gold Glove

I am part of history for this feat in a shutout ... and my parents were so damn proud

I did finish 3rd one season in the NL Cy Young award voting

I appeared in a World Series with the 2 teams in difft teams ... both lost and the 2nd team originally was from the city where with the team I played in my 1st WS with

I won a NL Comeback Player of the Year award

I started an All Star game in my 40s

I pitched over 3500 innings

[Old-Timer]

First Pitcher that came to mind was Catfish but I believe it's Rick Reuschel who pitched in the Earthquake series. He also started the all-star game that year.

[doc mercer]

That would be correct